Each holiday season, there are news articles, web sites and commentators who debate whether it is better for the environment to use an artificial Christmas tree or a natural Christmas tree. This can often be confusing to consumers who want to make an eco-friendly choice, but can’t find a simple, straight-forward “apples to apples” comparison. The table below illustrates that Real Christmas Trees are the best environmental choice.
Real Trees |
Artificial Trees |
Place of Origin |
|
|
|
| |
|
Method of Production |
|
|
|
- Planting takes place January - May
|
- Raw materials sent to factory & assembled into final product
|
- Estimated 40-45 million trees planted in 2008 in North America
|
- Product shipped to U.S. then distributed to stores
|
- estimated 46 million trees growing on farms in U.S.
|
- Number of factories unknown
|
- Tree farms support complex eco-systems
|
- Factories only consume natural resources
|
Components |
|
|
|
|
|
PVC Free? |
|
|
|
Lead Free? |
|
|
|
Carbon Neutral? |
|
|
|
- Trees absorb carbon dioxide
|
- Plastic is a petroleum byproduct
|
- When decomposting, carbon, nitrogen and other elements are released into the soil
|
|
Chemicals? |
|
|
|
- Scientists have measured cut Christmas trees for chemical residue and not found any significant amount
|
- PVC itself is a dangerous chemical
|
- Many different bugs, fungi and parasites attack and kill trees, so farmers may use pesticides to keep consumers' trees healthy and alive until harvest
|
- Manufacture of PVC creates and disperses dioxins, the most toxic man-made chemical known
|
- Most pesticides are ground applied
|
- Released into air and water, dioxins enter the food chain, where they accumulate in fatty tissues of animals and humans, a potential risk for causing cancer, damaging immune functions and imparing children's development
|
- Herbicides are used to supress, not kill off, weeds to prevent soil erosion
|
|
- If someone tells you "there are chemicals on cut Christmas Trees" they are wrong
|
|
Disposal |
|
|
|
- Used trees can be recycled in a variety of ways
|
- Fake trees can't be recycled and end up in landfills
|
- Decomposing trees add nutrients back into the earth
|
- All of the acumulated fake trees are a burden to the environment indefinitely
|
Renewable Resource? |
|
|
|
- New trees planted every year
|
- Petroleum, used to make plastic, is a non-renewable resource, as are metals
|
Eco-Friendly? |
|
|
|